Financials & FinTech research, Galliano’s Financials Research

Victor Galliano

Financials & FinTech research

Financials & FinTech, EM & Developed Markets

Galliano’s Financials Research

Galliano's Financials Research provides fundamental research in Emerging Markets financials, including FinTech, as well as financials in select Developed Markets.

The investment style applied is generally value oriented, although Growth At Reasonable Price (GARP) strategies can also be used where appropriate. 

Our investment research approach aim is often contrarian, looking to capitalise on overly sceptical or optimistic consensus views. In terms of valuation techniques, the focus is on PBV ratio to ROE, PE multiples and dividend yield, as well as the application of PEG ratios and, where appropriate, Sum of the Parts (SOTP) valuations.

Thematic (Sector/Industry)

<ul>
<li>Our key positive picks in payments are two Brazilian companies, <a href="https://www.smartkarma.com/entities/pagseguro-digital-ltd" target="_blank" data-smartkarma-citation="entities:27939:1" rel="noopener">Pagseguro Digital Ltd (PAGS US)</a> and <a href="https://www.smartkarma.com/entities/cielo-sa" target="_blank" data-smartkarma-citation="entities:24750:1" rel="noopener">Cielo SA (CIEL3 BZ)</a> </li>
<li>PagSeguro is our main pick, attractive on GARP metrics and with its higher take rate, it is our preference over its closest peer StoneCo</li>
<li>Cielo, the leading legacy payments company in Brazil, has seen its shares under pressure; yet fundamentals should be supported by the recent approval of WhatsApp Payments, given that Cielo is WhatsApp’s processor of payments</li>
<li>
<a href="https://www.smartkarma.com/entities/dlocal-ltd-uruguay" target="_blank" data-smartkarma-citation="entities:33377:1" rel="noopener">DLocal Ltd/Uruguay (DLO US)</a> listed on NASDAQ in early June; the shares are up by 150% from its IPO price, and, even given the growth potential, valuations are looking full, so we see an opportunity to take profits</li>
<li>
<a href="https://www.smartkarma.com/entities/square-inc" target="_blank" data-smartkarma-citation="entities:23755:1" rel="noopener">Square Inc (SQ US)</a> is another premium growth story, but one where we believe current valuations are running ahead of the fundamental prospects</li>
<li>
<a href="https://www.smartkarma.com/entities/paypal-holdings-inc" target="_blank" data-smartkarma-citation="entities:4747:1" rel="noopener">Paypal Holdings (PYPL US)</a>  and <a href="https://www.smartkarma.com/entities/mastercard-inc-class-a" target="_blank" data-smartkarma-citation="entities:15529:1" rel="noopener">Mastercard (MA US)</a>, although not as compelling on valuations as PagSeguro and Cielo, are also attractive stocks</li>
<li>Risks to our positive view on Cielo include lower than expected revenues from the WhatsApp Payments contract and for PagSeguro this includes a weaker than expected business climate for its core SME client base; risks to our negative calls on DLocal and Square include stronger than expected transaction activity and revenue generation going forward</li>
</ul>


Our key positive picks in payments are two Brazilian companies, Pagseguro Digital Ltd (PAGS US) and Cielo SA (CIEL3 BZ) 
PagSeguro is our main pick, attractive on GARP metrics and with its higher take rate, it is our preference over its closest peer StoneCo
Cielo, the leading legacy payments company in Brazil, has seen its shares under pressure; yet fundamentals should be supported by the recent approval of WhatsApp Payments, given that Cielo is WhatsApp’s processor of payments

DLocal Ltd/Uruguay (DLO US) listed on NASDAQ in early June; the shares are up by 150% from its IPO price, and, even given the growth potential, valuations are looking full, so we see an opportunity to take profits

Square Inc (SQ US) is another premium growth story, but one where we believe current valuations are running ahead of the fundamental prospects

Paypal Holdings (PYPL US)  and Mastercard (MA US), although not as compelling on valuations as PagSeguro and Cielo, are also attractive stocks
Risks to our positive view on Cielo include lower than expected revenues from the WhatsApp Payments contract and for PagSeguro this includes a weaker than expected business climate for its core SME client base; risks to our negative calls on DLocal and Square include stronger than expected transaction activity and revenue generation going forward


<ul>
<li>We upgrade <a href="https://www.smartkarma.com/entities/cielo-sa" target="_blank" data-smartkarma-citation="entities:24750:1" rel="noopener">Cielo SA (CIEL3 BZ)</a> to a buy, and downgrade <a href="https://www.smartkarma.com/entities/pagseguro-digital-ltd" target="_blank" data-smartkarma-citation="entities:27939:1" rel="noopener">Pagseguro Digital Ltd (PAGS US)</a> and <a href="https://www.smartkarma.com/entities/stoneco-ltd" target="_blank" data-smartkarma-citation="entities:27564:1" rel="noopener">StoneCo Ltd (STNE US)</a> to sell</li>
<li>Cielo is starting to retain market share, and the latest Merchant Discount Rate (MDR) data offers near term relief to the incumbent acquirers, in our view</li>
<li>Valuation multiple differentials appear to be largely reflecting the growth opportunity for the challengers, and under-estimating the incumbents' ability to generate lower, but still positive, returns</li>
<li>Capital IQ consensus earnings revisions indicate that the worst of the consensus earnings cuts for Cielo may be over; management is responding with improved customer service and reallocating resources to more productive tasks</li>
<li>For PagSeguro and StoneCo we believe that the most positive earnings revisions may be in the rear view mirror at least for now, as the Brazilian payments industry is a crowded space for challengers too</li>
<li>Risks to our view include worse than expected attrition of MDRs, a stubbornly high cost base at Cielo as well as stronger than expected market share gains and cost efficiencies derived by the challengers</li>
</ul>


We upgrade Cielo SA (CIEL3 BZ) to a buy, and downgrade Pagseguro Digital Ltd (PAGS US) and StoneCo Ltd (STNE US) to sell
Cielo is starting to retain market share, and the latest Merchant Discount Rate (MDR) data offers near term relief to the incumbent acquirers, in our view
Valuation multiple differentials appear to be largely reflecting the growth opportunity for the challengers, and under-estimating the incumbents' ability to generate lower, but still positive, returns
Capital IQ consensus earnings revisions indicate that the worst of the consensus earnings cuts for Cielo may be over; management is responding with improved customer service and reallocating resources to more productive tasks
For PagSeguro and StoneCo we believe that the most positive earnings revisions may be in the rear view mirror at least for now, as the Brazilian payments industry is a crowded space for challengers too
Risks to our view include worse than expected attrition of MDRs, a stubbornly high cost base at Cielo as well as stronger than expected market share gains and cost efficiencies derived by the challengers


Brazil Payment Companies; Rotating from Growth to Value - Buy Cielo, Sell Pagseguro, StoneCo

Accelerating Tomorrow’s Independent Research

Boost Research

Boost Research Ltd is an appointed representative of Messels Ltd which is authorised and regulated by the FCA of the UK. 

This document is issued by Boost Research Limited solely for its clients. It may not be reproduced, redistributed or passed to any other person in whole or in part for any purpose without written consent of Boost Research. The material in this document is not intended for distribution or use outside the United Kingdom. This material is not directed at you if Boost Research is prohibited or restricted by any legislation or regulation in any jurisdiction from making it available to you.

This document is provided for information purposes only and should not be regarded as an offer, solicitation, invitation, inducement or recommendation relating to the subscription, purchase or sale of any security or other financial instrument.  This document does not constitute, and should not be interpreted as, investment advice.  It is accordingly recommended that you should seek independent advice from a suitably qualified professional advisor before taking any decisions in relation to the investments detailed herein. All expressions of opinions and estimates constitute a judgement and, unless otherwise stated, are those of the author and the research department of Boost Research only, and are subject to change without notice. Boost Research is under no obligation to update the information contained herein. Whilst Boost Research has taken all reasonable care to ensure that the information contained in this document is not untrue or misleading at the time of publication, Boost Research cannot guarantee its accuracy or completeness, and you should not act on it without first independently verifying its contents. This document is not guaranteed to be a complete statement or summary of any securities, markets, reports or developments referred to herein. No representation or warranty either expressed or implied is made, nor responsibility of any kind is accepted, by Boost Research or any of its respective directors, officers, employees or analysts either as to the accuracy or completeness of any information contained in this document nor should it be relied on as such. No liability whatsoever is accepted by Boost Research or any of its respective directors, officers, employees or analysts for any loss, whether direct or consequential, arising whether directly or indirectly as a result of the recipient acting on the content of this document, including, without limitation, lost profits arising from the use of this document or any of its contents.

This document is provided with the understanding that Boost Research is not acting in a fiduciary capacity and it is not a personal recommendation to you. Investing in securities entails risks. Past performance is not necessarily a guide to future performance. The value of and the income produced by products may fluctuate, so that an investor may get back less than he invested. Investments in the entities and/or the securities or other financial instruments referred to are not suitable for all investors and this document should not be relied upon in substitution for the exercise of independent judgment in relation to any such investment. The stated price of any securities mentioned herein will generally be the closing price at the end of any of the three business days immediately prior to the publication date on this document. This stated price is not a representation that any transaction can be effected at this price.

Boost Research and its respective analysts are remunerated for providing investment research to professional investors, corporations, other research institutions and consultancy houses. Boost Research, or its respective directors, officers, employees and clients may have or take positions in the securities or entities mentioned in this document.  Any of these circumstances could create, or be perceived as creating, conflicts of interest. Boost Research’ analysts are not censored in any way and are free to express their personal opinions. As a result, Boost Research may have issued other documents that are inconsistent with and reach different conclusions from, the information contained in this document. Those documents reflect the different assumptions, views and analytical methods of their authors. No director, officer or employee of Boost Research is on the board of directors of any company referenced herein and no one at any such referenced company is on the board of directors of Boost Research.

Messels is authorised and regulated in the United Kingdom by the Financial Conduct Authority for the provision of investment advice. Residents of the United Kingdom should seek specific professional financial and investment advice from a stockbroker, banker, solicitor, accountant or other independent professional adviser authorised pursuant to the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000. This report is intended only for investors who are 'professional clients' as defined by the FCA, and may not, therefore, be redistributed to other classes of investors.

The content of this report is covered by our Policy of Independence which may be viewed at www.messels.com.

 

Analysts’ Certification

The analysts involved in the production of this document hereby certify that the views expressed in this document accurately reflect their personal views about the securities mentioned herein. The analysts point out that they may buy, sell or already have taken positions in the securities, and related financial instruments, mentioned in this document

<ul class="">
<li>The non-cash payments market continues to grow at a double-digit rate in Brazil, driven primarily by growing usage of credit and debit cards</li>
<li>De-regulation and new entrants have brought challenges for the incumbents, especially for the largest player <a href="https://www.smartkarma.com/entities/24750" target="_blank">Cielo SA (CIEL3 BZ)</a>, with the challengers taking market share, squeezing margins and promoting better service for SME merchants in particular</li>
<li>Competitive pressures continue in the Brazil payments market, reflected in the declining merchant discount rate (MDR), lower rental rates and sale prices for POS terminals, as well as pressure on the commissions for early payment of merchant receivables; the near-term prospects for Cielo remain challenging in our view</li>
<li>Due to the ongoing headwinds, we expect Cielo to show negative earnings growth to 2021; management has announced that Cielo will defend its market share against the challengers; we see further downside risk to consensus earnings and the real risk of a greater than consensus 2019 DPS cut</li>
<li>
<a href="https://www.smartkarma.com/entities/27564" target="_blank">StoneCo Ltd (STNE US)</a>and <a href="https://www.smartkarma.com/entities/27939" target="_blank">Pagseguro Digital Ltd (PAGS US)</a> are two of the payment challengers in this de-regulated market, growing faster than the Brazilian non-cash transactions market and taking incumbents' market share; we see StoneCo to be the preferred entity to PagSeguro, based on StoneCo’s higher revenue yielding SME segment of focus and on its more attractive PEG ratio valuation</li>
</ul>


The non-cash payments market continues to grow at a double-digit rate in Brazil, driven primarily by growing usage of credit and debit cards
De-regulation and new entrants have brought challenges for the incumbents, especially for the largest player Cielo SA (CIEL3 BZ), with the challengers taking market share, squeezing margins and promoting better service for SME merchants in particular
Competitive pressures continue in the Brazil payments market, reflected in the declining merchant discount rate (MDR), lower rental rates and sale prices for POS terminals, as well as pressure on the commissions for early payment of merchant receivables; the near-term prospects for Cielo remain challenging in our view
Due to the ongoing headwinds, we expect Cielo to show negative earnings growth to 2021; management has announced that Cielo will defend its market share against the challengers; we see further downside risk to consensus earnings and the real risk of a greater than consensus 2019 DPS cut

StoneCo Ltd (STNE US)and Pagseguro Digital Ltd (PAGS US) are two of the payment challengers in this de-regulated market, growing faster than the Brazilian non-cash transactions market and taking incumbents' market share; we see StoneCo to be the preferred entity to PagSeguro, based on StoneCo’s higher revenue yielding SME segment of focus and on its more attractive PEG ratio valuation


Brazilian Payments Report: Cielo on the Defensive Against Disruptive Challengers

Equity Capital Markets

<ul>
<li>Our initial PicPay report assumed a post-money IPO valuation of USD2.5bn; the disclosed price range implies an IPO valuation of USD2.07bn to USD2.53bn, with between USD365m and USD500m being raised</li>
<li>The key challenge we see for PicPay is credit quality; stage 3 loans to total loans have risen fast, despite secured loans accounting for 70%+ of the total</li>
<li>We believe that PicPay is more comparable to Banco Pan not Inter and certainly not Nubank; therefore, we see more appropriate IPO pricing at the bottom of the range (USD16)</li>
</ul>


Our initial PicPay report assumed a post-money IPO valuation of USD2.5bn; the disclosed price range implies an IPO valuation of USD2.07bn to USD2.53bn, with between USD365m and USD500m being raised
The key challenge we see for PicPay is credit quality; stage 3 loans to total loans have risen fast, despite secured loans accounting for 70%+ of the total
We believe that PicPay is more comparable to Banco Pan not Inter and certainly not Nubank; therefore, we see more appropriate IPO pricing at the bottom of the range (USD16)


PicPay Pre-IPO Revisited – Further Thoughts on Valuation

<ul>
<li>PicPay is a Brazilian fintech offering a range of digital banking and financial services including payments to consumer and small and medium business clients</li>
<li>No valuation range has been released yet for PicPay’s IPO, but press reports indicate a USD500m potential offering; we assume a post-money market capitalisation at IPO of USD2.5bn</li>
<li>PicPay is higher quality than Banco PAN, especially in terms of NPL ratio, but PicPay falls short, in terms of its operating metrics, versus Inter and well short of Nubank</li>
</ul>


PicPay is a Brazilian fintech offering a range of digital banking and financial services including payments to consumer and small and medium business clients
No valuation range has been released yet for PicPay’s IPO, but press reports indicate a USD500m potential offering; we assume a post-money market capitalisation at IPO of USD2.5bn
PicPay is higher quality than Banco PAN, especially in terms of NPL ratio, but PicPay falls short, in terms of its operating metrics, versus Inter and well short of Nubank


PicPay Pre-IPO Research – Initial Thoughts on Its Valuation Versus LatAm Fintechs

Brazil

StoneCo Ltd. is a Brazilian financial technology and software solutions provider. The company offers a cloud-based platform for payments, digital banking, and credit solutions primarily to micro, small, and medium businesses (MSMBs). It also provides Point of Sale (POS) and Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) solutions. Headquartered in George Town, Cayman Islands, StoneCo was founded in 2012.

Price Gauge
52-week Range	0.00 - 0.00
Market Cap (USDm)	0.00
P/E	0.00
Dividend (Yield)	0.00

StoneCo (STNE US)

Payments Companies – Our Core Picks

From our review of ten payments companies, we pick PagSeguro and Cielo as buys; we would take profits on recently listed DLocal and Square; other...

Victor Galliano

Brazil Payment Companies; Rotating from Growth to Value - Buy Cielo, Sell Pagseguro, StoneCo

We upgrade Cielo SA (CIEL3 BZ) to a buy, and downgrade Pagseguro Digital Ltd (PAGS US) and StoneCo Ltd (STNE US) to sell Cielo is starting to...

Victor Galliano

Brazilian Payments Report: Cielo on the Defensive Against Disruptive Challengers

The non-cash payments market continues to grow at a double-digit rate in Brazil, driven primarily by growing usage of credit and debit...

Boost Research

PicPay Pre-IPO Revisited – Further Thoughts on Valuation

PicPay's IPO valuation ranges from USD2.07bn to USD2.53bn, with credit quality as a key concern; we see Banco Pan as its key comparable, and...

Victor Galliano

PicPay Pre-IPO Research – Initial Thoughts on Its Valuation Versus LatAm Fintechs

We base Brazil fintech PicPay's initial IPO valuation on those of LatAm fintech peers. We see it as higher quality than Banco PAN but it lags...

Victor Galliano

Price Gauge

52-week Range

Market Cap (USDm)

P/E

Dividend (Yield)

Payments Companies – Our Core Picks

From our review of ten payments companies, we pick PagSeguro and Cielo as buys; we would take profits on recently listed DLocal and Square; other...

Victor Galliano

Brazil Payment Companies; Rotating from Growth to Value - Buy Cielo, Sell Pagseguro, StoneCo

We upgrade Cielo SA (CIEL3 BZ) to a buy, and downgrade Pagseguro Digital Ltd (PAGS US) and StoneCo Ltd (STNE US) to sell Cielo is starting to...

Victor Galliano

Brazilian Payments Report: Cielo on the Defensive Against Disruptive Challengers

The non-cash payments market continues to grow at a double-digit rate in Brazil, driven primarily by growing usage of credit and debit...

Boost Research

PicPay Pre-IPO Revisited – Further Thoughts on Valuation

​PicPay's IPO valuation ranges from USD2.07bn to USD2.53bn, with credit quality as a key concern; we see Banco Pan as its key comparable, and...

Victor Galliano

PicPay Pre-IPO Research – Initial Thoughts on Its Valuation Versus LatAm Fintechs

We base Brazil fintech PicPay's initial IPO valuation on those of LatAm fintech peers. We see it as higher quality than Banco PAN but it lags...

Victor Galliano

PicPay's IPO valuation ranges from USD2.07bn to USD2.53bn, with credit quality as a key concern; we see Banco Pan as its key comparable, and...