Pan-Asia Catalysts/Events, Quiddity Advisors

Travis Lundy

Pan-Asia Catalysts/Events

Quiddity Advisors

Event-Driven

<ul>
<li>On Friday, Toshiba investors got two bits of news which have been taken as non-bullish.</li>
<li>Affiliate and former subsidiary <a href="https://www.smartkarma.com/entities/kioxia" target="_blank" data-smartkarma-citation="entities:29243:1" rel="noopener">Kioxia (6600 JP)</a> announced it would cut wafer input volume by 30% starting in October, and Toshiba's announcement on the Privatisation process status implied some delay.</li>
<li>Today the shares are getting hit vs Peers. It's still a problem of lots of moving parts. </li>
</ul>


On Friday, Toshiba investors got two bits of news which have been taken as non-bullish.
Affiliate and former subsidiary Kioxia (6600 JP) announced it would cut wafer input volume by 30% starting in October, and Toshiba's announcement on the Privatisation process status implied some delay.
Today the shares are getting hit vs Peers. It's still a problem of lots of moving parts. 


<ul>
<li>Three interviews and comments by Senior Toshiba Boardmembers (chairperson and head of Special Committee) and the CEO prep the ground for a full company deal, or no deal.</li>
<li>If no deal, there's downside to the 5yr average Toshiba/Peers ratio. If you see 50% deal probability, at mid ¥6000s or better, IRRs are OK. But there is jump risk.</li>
<li>I don't see the activists just deciding to bail en masse if no deal. I think they take it further, which means I think the Board wants a deal.</li>
</ul>


Three interviews and comments by Senior Toshiba Boardmembers (chairperson and head of Special Committee) and the CEO prep the ground for a full company deal, or no deal.
If no deal, there's downside to the 5yr average Toshiba/Peers ratio. If you see 50% deal probability, at mid ¥6000s or better, IRRs are OK. But there is jump risk.
I don't see the activists just deciding to bail en masse if no deal. I think they take it further, which means I think the Board wants a deal.


Toshiba (6502 JP) Getting Closer to Crunch Time So Ongoing News "Leaks" Likely

Japan Specialist

Mark Chadwick

Equity Bottom-Up

<ul>
<li>NEC's buyback announcement sends a clear message that the MTP is on track and management feel the stock is undervalued</li>
<li>The recent IR DAY increased our conviction in the financial model. We were impressed with the improving pipeline of Open RAN customers</li>
<li>The stock is significantly undervalued, trading below book value, with improving ROE</li>
</ul>


NEC's buyback announcement sends a clear message that the MTP is on track and management feel the stock is undervalued
The recent IR DAY increased our conviction in the financial model. We were impressed with the improving pipeline of Open RAN customers
The stock is significantly undervalued, trading below book value, with improving ROE


<ul>
<li>Since late June when I recommended to not be long Toshiba vs Peers, Toshiba has fallen 9.5% vs Peers (-6% on its own and an equal-weighted Peer Basket is +3.9%).</li>
<li>If one assumes the likelihood of a privatisation has not gone down, and the likely takeout price is the same, back-end adjusted, probability-adjusted IRRs are up 6-8%, to decent levels.</li>
<li>This changes my recommendation from Bearish to Probability-Adjusted Bullish, but it is nuanced, and it is still a range trade.</li>
</ul>


Since late June when I recommended to not be long Toshiba vs Peers, Toshiba has fallen 9.5% vs Peers (-6% on its own and an equal-weighted Peer Basket is +3.9%).
If one assumes the likelihood of a privatisation has not gone down, and the likely takeout price is the same, back-end adjusted, probability-adjusted IRRs are up 6-8%, to decent levels.
This changes my recommendation from Bearish to Probability-Adjusted Bullish, but it is nuanced, and it is still a range trade.


Toshiba (6502) Update - No Longer Worthwhile to Be Short Toshiba Vs Peers

<ul>
<li>NEC is geared into two mega-trends that will drive 9% CAGR in EBITDA through 2025 </li>
<li>NEC is a beneficiary of DX (digital transformation) in Japan and global 5G, which are both just starting to take off </li>
<li>NEC Investment Day may be short-term catalyst, but it is the undervaluation relative to the long-term opportunity that is mispriced </li>
</ul>


NEC is geared into two mega-trends that will drive 9% CAGR in EBITDA through 2025 
NEC is a beneficiary of DX (digital transformation) in Japan and global 5G, which are both just starting to take off 
NEC Investment Day may be short-term catalyst, but it is the undervaluation relative to the long-term opportunity that is mispriced 


NEC (6701) | Significantly Undervalued with Upcoming Catalyst

Japan

NEC Corporation manufactures and markets computers, telecommunication equipment, electronic devices, semiconductors, and software.  The Company's products include printers, modems, cellular phones, plasma display panels (PDP), network systems, memory, integrated circuits (IC), thin film transistor-liquid crystal display (TFT-LCD), and printed circuit boards (PCB). NEC operates worldwide.

Price Gauge
52-week Range	0.00 - 0.00
Market Cap (USDm)	0.00
P/E	0.00
Dividend (Yield)	0.00

NEC Corp (6701 JP)

Two Bits of Non-Bullish Toshiba News

Toshiba's possible deal timeline extended just as semi sector troubles start to make themselves better-known. Not bullish. But not hugely bearish....

Travis Lundy

Toshiba (6502 JP) Getting Closer to Crunch Time So Ongoing News "Leaks" Likely

Bidders are approaching 2nd Round deadlines, and news/comments are starting to seep out. Expect more. I expect a decision at/after H1 results. If...

Travis Lundy

NEC (6701) | Even Higher Conviction

NEC offers a unique combination of a discounted valuation today with a clear structural growth story across the thematic areas of DX and 5G. Recent...

Mark Chadwick

Toshiba (6502) Update - No Longer Worthwhile to Be Short Toshiba Vs Peers

The IRR to be obtained by buying Toshiba and expecting Probability X% of a Privatisation and (1-X%) of no deal has gone up sharply since end-June....

Travis Lundy

NEC (6701) | Significantly Undervalued with Upcoming Catalyst

NEC is a key beneficiary of DX in Japan and global 5G, which are both just starting to take off. We believe that there is at least 50% upside to...

Mark Chadwick

Price Gauge

52-week Range

Market Cap (USDm)

P/E

Dividend (Yield)