Telco/Internet specialist

Kirk Boodry

Redex Research

Equity Bottom-Up

<ul>
<li>NAV/Share is the lowest since July 2020 largely driven by declines in Alibaba shares (-8% this week and -61% from all-time highs)</li>
<li>A US de-listing for Didi is not necessarily good news for Softbank as the value of that stake will be determined by pricing for a HK listing</li>
<li>The NAV discount has returned to 48% as a less aggressive buyback program does little to drive the share price (not necessarily bad over the long run)</li>
</ul>


NAV/Share is the lowest since July 2020 largely driven by declines in Alibaba shares (-8% this week and -61% from all-time highs)
A US de-listing for Didi is not necessarily good news for Softbank as the value of that stake will be determined by pricing for a HK listing
The NAV discount has returned to 48% as a less aggressive buyback program does little to drive the share price (not necessarily bad over the long run)


Softbank Group - A Very Bad Week as China Drives NAV Weakness and Discount Round Trip

<ul>
<li>PayTM shares fell 27% in their debut as investors seem unhappy with loss-making companies.  Policy Bazaar's Monday listing was better (+40%) but it's not a good sign for Oyo</li>
<li>This is the seventh Q3 listing event for Vision Fund after little activity in Q2 and is consistent with weak performance for 2021 IPOs in general</li>
<li>The buyback is doing its job with shares up 13% in two weeks with the discount moving from 48%to 43%.  We have updated our Softbank and VF tables below</li>
</ul>


PayTM shares fell 27% in their debut as investors seem unhappy with loss-making companies.  Policy Bazaar's Monday listing was better (+40%) but it's not a good sign for Oyo
This is the seventh Q3 listing event for Vision Fund after little activity in Q2 and is consistent with weak performance for 2021 IPOs in general
The buyback is doing its job with shares up 13% in two weeks with the discount moving from 48%to 43%.  We have updated our Softbank and VF tables below


Softbank Group Mixed Early Results for Indian IPOs

These are our initial thoughts – we will write more about the quarter later – but we wanted to get our initial thoughts on the buyback out.This was a terrible print for <a href="https://www.smartkarma.com/entities/softbank-group-corp" target="_blank" data-smartkarma-citation="entities:315:1" rel="noopener">Softbank Group (9984 JP)</a>  which posted record investment losses for Vision Fund despite some fancy footwork on valuations in the private portfolio. That seems to make the announcement of a ¥1,000bn share buyback less surprising. No doubt it will attract interest as the shares trade near 52-week lows and at the high-end of the holding company discount range but there are some caveats that may temper enthusiasm whilst the longer-term risk is that the buyback is tied to completion of the Nvidia/ARM deal, which still faces regulatory scrutiny.

These are our initial thoughts – we will write more about the quarter later – but we wanted to get our initial thoughts on the buyback out.This was a terrible print for Softbank Group (9984 JP)  which posted record investment losses for Vision Fund despite some fancy footwork on valuations in the private portfolio. That seems to make the announcement of a ¥1,000bn share buyback less surprising. No doubt it will attract interest as the shares trade near 52-week lows and at the high-end of the holding company discount range but there are some caveats that may temper enthusiasm whilst the longer-term risk is that the buyback is tied to completion of the Nvidia/ARM deal, which still faces regulatory scrutiny.   

Softbank Group Q2 21 Results Reaction: Softbank May Intend to Use ARM Proceeds for Buyback

Latest News from the World’s Leading Innovators

Granite Bay Capital

An innovation focussed investment company

Granite Bay Capital is an innovation focussed investment company with a deep focus on the companies at the leading edge of innovation across major themes such as AI, ubiquitous computing, sustainability, automation and longevity.

Thematic (Sector/Industry)

<h2>Headline Development</h2>Hertz (HTZZ) just made the largest EV purchase ever, acquiring 100k Teslas (TLSA) for a reported $4.2b - half of which will go to Uber (UBER) drivers.  On top of this, Hertz will also invest significantly in EV charging infrastructure across its global operations.

Headline DevelopmentHertz (HTZZ) just made the largest EV purchase ever, acquiring 100k Teslas (TLSA) for a reported $4.2b - half of which will go to Uber (UBER) drivers.  On top of this, Hertz will also invest significantly in EV charging infrastructure across its global operations.

Equity Capital Markets

The Oyo listing should be a win for Softbank Group, which owns 47% (pre-listing) for a mere $1.1bn but initial pricing talk of $10-12bn seems wildly optimistic when matched against comparable valuations for premium online travel companies like Airbnb (implied Oyo value $4bn) or India tech ($7bn). Last year we thought this was worthless, so the turnaround is a pleasant surprise but we would not be buyers over INR 80/share ($7bn).

The Oyo listing should be a win for Softbank Group, which owns 47% (pre-listing) for a mere $1.1bn but initial pricing talk of $10-12bn seems wildly optimistic when matched against comparable valuations for premium online travel companies like Airbnb (implied Oyo value $4bn) or India tech ($7bn). Last year we thought this was worthless, so the turnaround is a pleasant surprise but we would not be buyers over INR 80/share ($7bn).

Oyo and Softbank Group - This Would Be Generously Valued at $4-7bn but that Keeps CEO Under Water

United States

WeWork Inc. provides co-working spaces for individuals and entrepreneurs. The Company offers private offices, office suites, headquarters, and custom build out options to fit a variety of office needs, as well as desk spaces and conference rooms. WeWork serves customers worldwide.

Price Gauge
52-week Range	0.00 - 0.00
Market Cap (USDm)	0.00
P/E	0.00
Dividend (Yield)	0.00

WeWork (WEWKQ US)

Softbank Group - A Very Bad Week as China Drives NAV Weakness and Discount Round Trip

Softbank's value is still tied to Alibaba and other China investments even with a robust buyback. NAV is the lowest since July 2020 and the...

Kirk Boodry

Softbank Group Mixed Early Results for Indian IPOs

PayTM has fallen 27% on its debut and whilst Policy Bazaar's Monday listing was better (+40%) it's not a good sign for the upcoming Oyo IPO. We...

Kirk Boodry

Softbank Group Q2 21 Results Reaction: Softbank May Intend to Use ARM Proceeds for Buyback

Softbank's share buyback may have as much to do with delays to Nvidia/ARM regulatory approval as record losses for Vision Fund in Q2. We look at...

Kirk Boodry

Weekly Innovation Review (WIRE) #55

Hertz (HTZZ) just made the largest EV purchase ever, acquiring 100k Teslas (TLSA) for a reported $4.2b - half of which will go...

Granite Bay Capital

Oyo and Softbank Group - This Would Be Generously Valued at $4-7bn but that Keeps CEO Under Water

An Oyo listing is a likely win for Softbank, which owns 47% for a mere $1.1bn but pricing talk of $10-12bn is optimistic compared to the $4-7bn...

Kirk Boodry

Price Gauge

52-week Range

Market Cap (USDm)

P/E

Dividend (Yield)