Consumer

In this briefing:

1. A Comparison of Recent Visitors Trend to Korea and Japan
2. This Week in Blockchain & Cryptos: Revisiting LINE’s Crypto Plans
3. GrainCorp (GNC AU): Pressure Mounts, Diminishing the Prospects of a Bump to the LTAP Bid
4. LG Uplus: Risks Now Largely Priced In. Raise to Neutral on CJ Hello Deal Synergies

1. A Comparison of Recent Visitors Trend to Korea and Japan

• In this report, we compare the recent dynamic foreign tourists trend to Korea and Japan. In January 2019, the number of foreign visitors to Japan rose 7.5% YoY to 2.69 million. A total of 0.78 million from South Korea visited Japan in January (DOWN 3% YoY) followed by 0.75 million people from China (up 19.3% YoY).
• According to Korea Ministry of Economy & Finance (MoEF), the number of people from China to Korea increased 35.1% YoY in January 2019.
• As evidenced by the better than expected Chinese visitors to Korea and worse than expected South Korean visitors to Japan in January, there is an increasing indication that this trend could continue in 2019. Many of the Korean related cosmetics stocks have positively reacted to the recent data. One of the interesting trades to be long on a basket of Korean cosmetics related stocks and be short on a basket of Japanese cosmetics related names. 

2. This Week in Blockchain & Cryptos: Revisiting LINE’s Crypto Plans

LINE Corp (3938 JP) is one of the top Japanese names in our “Watchlist” of listed companies in Japan and South Korea that are adopting blockchain technologies or have exposure to cryptocurrencies. 

Since being added to the “Watchlist” in May last year (2018), LINE has launched a cryptocurrency, a cryptocurrency exchange, and a blockchain venture fund. In this note, we revisit LINE’s blockchain and cryptocurrency plans.

3. GrainCorp (GNC AU): Pressure Mounts, Diminishing the Prospects of a Bump to the LTAP Bid

Frustration on the slow progress of the LTAP bid came to a head at the recent AGM, where shareholders registered what appeared to be protest votes aimed at Graincorp Ltd A (GNC AU)’s director elections and remuneration. The Board has currently three options to unlock shareholder value – achieve a binding LTAP bid, commence the portfolio review driven sale process or adopt the Tanarra Capital proposal.

4. LG Uplus: Risks Now Largely Priced In. Raise to Neutral on CJ Hello Deal Synergies

LG Uplus (032640 KS) shares have fallen around 20% from the highs of January when the market was excited by 5G. That always seemed overly optimistic given the lack of viable business cases and unknown investment requirements and we were comfortable with our Sell rating from mid October and KRW15,000 target price.  Following weak results, an easing of 5G  enthusiasm and the recently announced CJ Hello (037560 KS) deal the share price has fallen to around the KRW15,000. Alastair Jones now thinks a lot of bad news is in the price and the available synergies from CJ Hello offset a weaker earnings outlook. 

In this briefing:

1. Tesla Bonds Go Boom
2. Hankyu Invests ¥1.75 Billion in Hankyu Men’s Tokyo
3. After Zozo: Onward Sets Sights on Digital Renaissance
4. Snippets #21: Bremain, TMB Rights Issue
5. CATL Could Be Tesla’s New Battery Supplier- Panasonic in Trouble?

1. Tesla Bonds Go Boom

Remember last week when Tesla Motors (TSLA US) was set to dazzle the world with the eagerly awaited unveiling of the long-promised Model Y, on Pi Day! (see my report Tesla: Now We Know the Y But Not the How). Good times. 

Then, this happened:

• Model Y turned out to look and act just like Model 3, but with unconvincing features (third-row seat? Seriously?) and a much later than expected delivery target in 2020-2021 when, I warned, it could be so outdated it’s competitively irrelevant.
• CEO Elon Musk escalated his fight in the federal court considering the charge of contempt against him lodged by the SEC with a palpably arrogant defense. The SEC said Musk’s “brazen disregard of this court’s order is unacceptable and unworkable going forward.”
• Tesla made dubious claims about orders and deliveries that seems to be more alarming than inspiring to investors already spooked by the company’s calamitous strategy blunders which seem to be increasingly fueled by severe liquidity pressure (see Tesla’s Plan B 2.0; Y Not and Tesla: Now We Know the Y But Not the How).

Which means Tesla stock and bonds closed this week near six-month lows, with the spread on the benchmark 5.3% notes trading at a record 600 bps on Friday as they slumped back to 85.

Read on as Bond Angle analysis continues.

2. Hankyu Invests ¥1.75 Billion in Hankyu Men’s Tokyo

Hankyu Hanshin has outperformed the department store sector in the last few years and continues to invest to lock in its dominance of the Osaka market.

It is now about to unveil a major new update to its Tokyo store, creating a more luxurious Men’s Emporium.

The investment is an example of how the better department stores are repositioning individual buildings to better meet target market needs and find relevance in an e-commerce age.

3. After Zozo: Onward Sets Sights on Digital Renaissance

Onward Holdings (8016 JP) made a bold stand against price discounts in January when it announced plans to stop selling on ZOZO (3092 JP) but the timing was not ideal as Onward lowered its FY2018 sales guidance shortly thereafter..

With Zozo no longer a partner, Onward is investing in the growth of its own e-commerce business and has installed a new 50-person digital strategy group to make this happen.

If the plan works, Onward could finally break away from its dependence on the contracting department store apparel market but the journey to reach this goal will be a long one.

4. Snippets #21: Bremain, TMB Rights Issue

These are the five developments/news flows/trends and their potential impact on Thai equities you should be aware of in recent weeks: 

• Reversing Brexit. A special report highlighting the possible reversal of Brexit should have limited impact on Thai equities, though a few names like SSI, Thai Union, and Minor do float up on the screen.
• TMB announces a 5 for 1 rights issue at Bt2.07/sh, which could raise US$570m of new capital for their acquisition of Thanchart and imply a 65-35 split of ownership between the two banks.
• Politically motivated wage hike. Some of the political campaigns by smaller parties are even more populist than the major parties, implying wage increases between 10-30% from current levels. This could really destabilize Thailand’s long-term prospects as an investment base. 
• Italian-Thai Chairman thrown into prison. Premchai Karnasutra, who killed one of Thailand’s last 9 black leopards, is sentenced to 16 months in jail. Share prices actually rose!
• Bangkok’s third airport! The Navy is putting up the UTaPao airport construction up for bid. Front runners include the CP-led consortium, which includes ITD, but contenders include the BTS-STEC consortium and another smaller one.

5. CATL Could Be Tesla’s New Battery Supplier- Panasonic in Trouble?

The news released on the 11^th of March, about Tesla Motors (TSLA US) choosing CATL (A) (300750 CH) as battery supplier has focused much attention on the two companies and other battery suppliers. CATL which grabbed Panasonic Corp (6752 JP)’s leading position in the industry last year now seems to be grabbing the latter’s key customer as well. The news circulating states that, CATL could power Tesla’s Model 3 cars which Tesla is planning to start assembling at Tesla’s new factory near Shanghai. Following the release of this supposed deal, the stocks of the two companies moved positively, with CATL surging by almost 6.7% while Tesla rose by almost 2.4% during the day.  However, both parties have not commented on this news yet or made any formal announcement regarding such a potential deal. In our Insight, Tesla Drifting Away Could Leave Panasonic Struggling to Gain Traction in China, we mentioned that Tesla was looking to locally source its batteries in China and that CATL could potentially be one such supplier. However, in January this year, it was reported that Tesla had signed a preliminary agreement with China’s Tianjin Lishen to supply batteries for its new Shanghai car factory, making the current news look less believable. Although it seems like the ongoing news about a Tesla-CATL pair up lacks integrity, with CATL sort of denying its intend to work with Tesla (according to an updated news release), the news does look interesting and its effect upon the related companies seems noteworthy.

In this briefing:

1. This Week in Blockchain & Cryptos: Revisiting LINE’s Crypto Plans
2. GrainCorp (GNC AU): Pressure Mounts, Diminishing the Prospects of a Bump to the LTAP Bid
3. LG Uplus: Risks Now Largely Priced In. Raise to Neutral on CJ Hello Deal Synergies

1. This Week in Blockchain & Cryptos: Revisiting LINE’s Crypto Plans

LINE Corp (3938 JP) is one of the top Japanese names in our “Watchlist” of listed companies in Japan and South Korea that are adopting blockchain technologies or have exposure to cryptocurrencies. 

Since being added to the “Watchlist” in May last year (2018), LINE has launched a cryptocurrency, a cryptocurrency exchange, and a blockchain venture fund. In this note, we revisit LINE’s blockchain and cryptocurrency plans.

2. GrainCorp (GNC AU): Pressure Mounts, Diminishing the Prospects of a Bump to the LTAP Bid

Frustration on the slow progress of the LTAP bid came to a head at the recent AGM, where shareholders registered what appeared to be protest votes aimed at Graincorp Ltd A (GNC AU)’s director elections and remuneration. The Board has currently three options to unlock shareholder value – achieve a binding LTAP bid, commence the portfolio review driven sale process or adopt the Tanarra Capital proposal.

3. LG Uplus: Risks Now Largely Priced In. Raise to Neutral on CJ Hello Deal Synergies

LG Uplus (032640 KS) shares have fallen around 20% from the highs of January when the market was excited by 5G. That always seemed overly optimistic given the lack of viable business cases and unknown investment requirements and we were comfortable with our Sell rating from mid October and KRW15,000 target price.  Following weak results, an easing of 5G  enthusiasm and the recently announced CJ Hello (037560 KS) deal the share price has fallen to around the KRW15,000. Alastair Jones now thinks a lot of bad news is in the price and the available synergies from CJ Hello offset a weaker earnings outlook. 

In this briefing:

1. This Week in Blockchain & Cryptos: Revisiting LINE’s Crypto Plans
2. GrainCorp (GNC AU): Pressure Mounts, Diminishing the Prospects of a Bump to the LTAP Bid
3. LG Uplus: Risks Now Largely Priced In. Raise to Neutral on CJ Hello Deal Synergies
4. MAJOR: Impressive 4Q18 Earnings

1. This Week in Blockchain & Cryptos: Revisiting LINE’s Crypto Plans

LINE Corp (3938 JP) is one of the top Japanese names in our “Watchlist” of listed companies in Japan and South Korea that are adopting blockchain technologies or have exposure to cryptocurrencies. 

Since being added to the “Watchlist” in May last year (2018), LINE has launched a cryptocurrency, a cryptocurrency exchange, and a blockchain venture fund. In this note, we revisit LINE’s blockchain and cryptocurrency plans.

2. GrainCorp (GNC AU): Pressure Mounts, Diminishing the Prospects of a Bump to the LTAP Bid

Frustration on the slow progress of the LTAP bid came to a head at the recent AGM, where shareholders registered what appeared to be protest votes aimed at Graincorp Ltd A (GNC AU)’s director elections and remuneration. The Board has currently three options to unlock shareholder value – achieve a binding LTAP bid, commence the portfolio review driven sale process or adopt the Tanarra Capital proposal.

3. LG Uplus: Risks Now Largely Priced In. Raise to Neutral on CJ Hello Deal Synergies

LG Uplus (032640 KS) shares have fallen around 20% from the highs of January when the market was excited by 5G. That always seemed overly optimistic given the lack of viable business cases and unknown investment requirements and we were comfortable with our Sell rating from mid October and KRW15,000 target price.  Following weak results, an easing of 5G  enthusiasm and the recently announced CJ Hello (037560 KS) deal the share price has fallen to around the KRW15,000. Alastair Jones now thinks a lot of bad news is in the price and the available synergies from CJ Hello offset a weaker earnings outlook. 

4. MAJOR: Impressive 4Q18 Earnings

MAJOR 4Q18 net profit was Bt259m (+247%YoY, +26%QoQ). The impressive earnings was driven by solid guests admission (+97%YoY).

• 4Q18 revenue was Bt3.0bn (+59%YoY, +44% QoQ). Interesting movies lineup was the factor, pushing admission revenue (+88%YoY) and concession revenue (+70%YoY).
• Gross profit margin was strong at 37.6% from 28.7% in 4Q17 and 30.8% in 3Q18, thank to the higher contribution of concession revenue, which has decent margin.
• SG&A to sales was under control at 27.0%, compared to 34.3% in 4Q17 and 26.7% in 3Q18.

We maintain a BUY rating on MAJOR with 2019E target price of Bt31.00, derived from a PER of 24.2x, which is +1 SD of its 3-year trading average. We expect MAJOR to continuously deliver robust earnings in 2019E, given the fascinating movies lineup and advertising sales model changing from direct selling to selling through agencies.

In this briefing:

1. Hankyu Invests ¥1.75 Billion in Hankyu Men’s Tokyo
2. After Zozo: Onward Sets Sights on Digital Renaissance
3. Snippets #21: Bremain, TMB Rights Issue
4. CATL Could Be Tesla’s New Battery Supplier- Panasonic in Trouble?
5. Is There Still a Bright Future for FutureBright?

1. Hankyu Invests ¥1.75 Billion in Hankyu Men’s Tokyo

Hankyu Hanshin has outperformed the department store sector in the last few years and continues to invest to lock in its dominance of the Osaka market.

It is now about to unveil a major new update to its Tokyo store, creating a more luxurious Men’s Emporium.

The investment is an example of how the better department stores are repositioning individual buildings to better meet target market needs and find relevance in an e-commerce age.

2. After Zozo: Onward Sets Sights on Digital Renaissance

Onward Holdings (8016 JP) made a bold stand against price discounts in January when it announced plans to stop selling on ZOZO (3092 JP) but the timing was not ideal as Onward lowered its FY2018 sales guidance shortly thereafter..

With Zozo no longer a partner, Onward is investing in the growth of its own e-commerce business and has installed a new 50-person digital strategy group to make this happen.

If the plan works, Onward could finally break away from its dependence on the contracting department store apparel market but the journey to reach this goal will be a long one.

3. Snippets #21: Bremain, TMB Rights Issue

These are the five developments/news flows/trends and their potential impact on Thai equities you should be aware of in recent weeks: 

• Reversing Brexit. A special report highlighting the possible reversal of Brexit should have limited impact on Thai equities, though a few names like SSI, Thai Union, and Minor do float up on the screen.
• TMB announces a 5 for 1 rights issue at Bt2.07/sh, which could raise US$570m of new capital for their acquisition of Thanchart and imply a 65-35 split of ownership between the two banks.
• Politically motivated wage hike. Some of the political campaigns by smaller parties are even more populist than the major parties, implying wage increases between 10-30% from current levels. This could really destabilize Thailand’s long-term prospects as an investment base. 
• Italian-Thai Chairman thrown into prison. Premchai Karnasutra, who killed one of Thailand’s last 9 black leopards, is sentenced to 16 months in jail. Share prices actually rose!
• Bangkok’s third airport! The Navy is putting up the UTaPao airport construction up for bid. Front runners include the CP-led consortium, which includes ITD, but contenders include the BTS-STEC consortium and another smaller one.

4. CATL Could Be Tesla’s New Battery Supplier- Panasonic in Trouble?

The news released on the 11^th of March, about Tesla Motors (TSLA US) choosing CATL (A) (300750 CH) as battery supplier has focused much attention on the two companies and other battery suppliers. CATL which grabbed Panasonic Corp (6752 JP)’s leading position in the industry last year now seems to be grabbing the latter’s key customer as well. The news circulating states that, CATL could power Tesla’s Model 3 cars which Tesla is planning to start assembling at Tesla’s new factory near Shanghai. Following the release of this supposed deal, the stocks of the two companies moved positively, with CATL surging by almost 6.7% while Tesla rose by almost 2.4% during the day.  However, both parties have not commented on this news yet or made any formal announcement regarding such a potential deal. In our Insight, Tesla Drifting Away Could Leave Panasonic Struggling to Gain Traction in China, we mentioned that Tesla was looking to locally source its batteries in China and that CATL could potentially be one such supplier. However, in January this year, it was reported that Tesla had signed a preliminary agreement with China’s Tianjin Lishen to supply batteries for its new Shanghai car factory, making the current news look less believable. Although it seems like the ongoing news about a Tesla-CATL pair up lacks integrity, with CATL sort of denying its intend to work with Tesla (according to an updated news release), the news does look interesting and its effect upon the related companies seems noteworthy.

5. Is There Still a Bright Future for FutureBright?

Almost 12 months after posting our initial thesis on Future Bright Holdings (703 HK)Gambling on a Bright Future, we review FutureBright’s most recent results, raising questions on whether stalling improvement in the core restaurant business performance warrants taking chips off the table while waiting for key catalysts to materialise.

In this briefing:

1. LG Uplus: Risks Now Largely Priced In. Raise to Neutral on CJ Hello Deal Synergies
2. MAJOR: Impressive 4Q18 Earnings
3. BGF Duo Stub Trade: Short Sub / Long Holdco with a Very Short-Term Horizon

1. LG Uplus: Risks Now Largely Priced In. Raise to Neutral on CJ Hello Deal Synergies

LG Uplus (032640 KS) shares have fallen around 20% from the highs of January when the market was excited by 5G. That always seemed overly optimistic given the lack of viable business cases and unknown investment requirements and we were comfortable with our Sell rating from mid October and KRW15,000 target price.  Following weak results, an easing of 5G  enthusiasm and the recently announced CJ Hello (037560 KS) deal the share price has fallen to around the KRW15,000. Alastair Jones now thinks a lot of bad news is in the price and the available synergies from CJ Hello offset a weaker earnings outlook. 

2. MAJOR: Impressive 4Q18 Earnings

MAJOR 4Q18 net profit was Bt259m (+247%YoY, +26%QoQ). The impressive earnings was driven by solid guests admission (+97%YoY).

• 4Q18 revenue was Bt3.0bn (+59%YoY, +44% QoQ). Interesting movies lineup was the factor, pushing admission revenue (+88%YoY) and concession revenue (+70%YoY).
• Gross profit margin was strong at 37.6% from 28.7% in 4Q17 and 30.8% in 3Q18, thank to the higher contribution of concession revenue, which has decent margin.
• SG&A to sales was under control at 27.0%, compared to 34.3% in 4Q17 and 26.7% in 3Q18.

We maintain a BUY rating on MAJOR with 2019E target price of Bt31.00, derived from a PER of 24.2x, which is +1 SD of its 3-year trading average. We expect MAJOR to continuously deliver robust earnings in 2019E, given the fascinating movies lineup and advertising sales model changing from direct selling to selling through agencies.

3. BGF Duo Stub Trade: Short Sub / Long Holdco with a Very Short-Term Horizon

• The BGF Holdco/Sub duo is making a very dynamic movement. Yesterday, they made a 2σ jump. Sub went up 5.38%. Holdco stayed flat with a 0.24% gain. The day before yesterday, they made an exact opposite movement. Holdco was up 2%. Sub suffered a 3% loss. This also resulted in a 2σ jump, just the opposite way.
• Still, local street sentiments are heavily divided on Sub’s fundamentals. There is no news or anything that may possibly reverse the tide at this point. Shorting on Sub is still going very strong. It seems that a lot of short-term traders both at home and abroad are trading on the duo lately.
• On a 120D horizon, Holdco is still undervalued relative to Sub by about 10%. The duo should be again reverted back to a mean in favor of Holdco today. I’d suggest going long Holdco and short Sub now if you had closed the previous position which we initiated last week on Feb 13.

In this briefing:

1. LG Uplus: Risks Now Largely Priced In. Raise to Neutral on CJ Hello Deal Synergies
2. MAJOR: Impressive 4Q18 Earnings
3. BGF Duo Stub Trade: Short Sub / Long Holdco with a Very Short-Term Horizon
4. New Century Hotel Mgmt IPO Preview: Two-Speed Businesses

1. LG Uplus: Risks Now Largely Priced In. Raise to Neutral on CJ Hello Deal Synergies

LG Uplus (032640 KS) shares have fallen around 20% from the highs of January when the market was excited by 5G. That always seemed overly optimistic given the lack of viable business cases and unknown investment requirements and we were comfortable with our Sell rating from mid October and KRW15,000 target price.  Following weak results, an easing of 5G  enthusiasm and the recently announced CJ Hello (037560 KS) deal the share price has fallen to around the KRW15,000. Alastair Jones now thinks a lot of bad news is in the price and the available synergies from CJ Hello offset a weaker earnings outlook. 

2. MAJOR: Impressive 4Q18 Earnings

MAJOR 4Q18 net profit was Bt259m (+247%YoY, +26%QoQ). The impressive earnings was driven by solid guests admission (+97%YoY).

• 4Q18 revenue was Bt3.0bn (+59%YoY, +44% QoQ). Interesting movies lineup was the factor, pushing admission revenue (+88%YoY) and concession revenue (+70%YoY).
• Gross profit margin was strong at 37.6% from 28.7% in 4Q17 and 30.8% in 3Q18, thank to the higher contribution of concession revenue, which has decent margin.
• SG&A to sales was under control at 27.0%, compared to 34.3% in 4Q17 and 26.7% in 3Q18.

We maintain a BUY rating on MAJOR with 2019E target price of Bt31.00, derived from a PER of 24.2x, which is +1 SD of its 3-year trading average. We expect MAJOR to continuously deliver robust earnings in 2019E, given the fascinating movies lineup and advertising sales model changing from direct selling to selling through agencies.

3. BGF Duo Stub Trade: Short Sub / Long Holdco with a Very Short-Term Horizon

• The BGF Holdco/Sub duo is making a very dynamic movement. Yesterday, they made a 2σ jump. Sub went up 5.38%. Holdco stayed flat with a 0.24% gain. The day before yesterday, they made an exact opposite movement. Holdco was up 2%. Sub suffered a 3% loss. This also resulted in a 2σ jump, just the opposite way.
• Still, local street sentiments are heavily divided on Sub’s fundamentals. There is no news or anything that may possibly reverse the tide at this point. Shorting on Sub is still going very strong. It seems that a lot of short-term traders both at home and abroad are trading on the duo lately.
• On a 120D horizon, Holdco is still undervalued relative to Sub by about 10%. The duo should be again reverted back to a mean in favor of Holdco today. I’d suggest going long Holdco and short Sub now if you had closed the previous position which we initiated last week on Feb 13.

4. New Century Hotel Mgmt IPO Preview: Two-Speed Businesses

Zhejiang New Century Hotel Management Group (ZHEKAIH HK)  is a leading hotel group in China engaged in the operation and management of mid-scale and upscale hotel chains. New Century has started pre-marketing for a Hong Kong IPO to raise up to $200 million, according to press reports.

In this briefing:

1. Snippets #21: Bremain, TMB Rights Issue
2. CATL Could Be Tesla’s New Battery Supplier- Panasonic in Trouble?
3. Is There Still a Bright Future for FutureBright?
4. Navitas Gets An Agreed Deal with BGH
5. Navitas (NVT AU): BGH Heads Towards Its First Major Acquisition

1. Snippets #21: Bremain, TMB Rights Issue

These are the five developments/news flows/trends and their potential impact on Thai equities you should be aware of in recent weeks: 

• Reversing Brexit. A special report highlighting the possible reversal of Brexit should have limited impact on Thai equities, though a few names like SSI, Thai Union, and Minor do float up on the screen.
• TMB announces a 5 for 1 rights issue at Bt2.07/sh, which could raise US$570m of new capital for their acquisition of Thanchart and imply a 65-35 split of ownership between the two banks.
• Politically motivated wage hike. Some of the political campaigns by smaller parties are even more populist than the major parties, implying wage increases between 10-30% from current levels. This could really destabilize Thailand’s long-term prospects as an investment base. 
• Italian-Thai Chairman thrown into prison. Premchai Karnasutra, who killed one of Thailand’s last 9 black leopards, is sentenced to 16 months in jail. Share prices actually rose!
• Bangkok’s third airport! The Navy is putting up the UTaPao airport construction up for bid. Front runners include the CP-led consortium, which includes ITD, but contenders include the BTS-STEC consortium and another smaller one.

2. CATL Could Be Tesla’s New Battery Supplier- Panasonic in Trouble?

The news released on the 11^th of March, about Tesla Motors (TSLA US) choosing CATL (A) (300750 CH) as battery supplier has focused much attention on the two companies and other battery suppliers. CATL which grabbed Panasonic Corp (6752 JP)’s leading position in the industry last year now seems to be grabbing the latter’s key customer as well. The news circulating states that, CATL could power Tesla’s Model 3 cars which Tesla is planning to start assembling at Tesla’s new factory near Shanghai. Following the release of this supposed deal, the stocks of the two companies moved positively, with CATL surging by almost 6.7% while Tesla rose by almost 2.4% during the day.  However, both parties have not commented on this news yet or made any formal announcement regarding such a potential deal. In our Insight, Tesla Drifting Away Could Leave Panasonic Struggling to Gain Traction in China, we mentioned that Tesla was looking to locally source its batteries in China and that CATL could potentially be one such supplier. However, in January this year, it was reported that Tesla had signed a preliminary agreement with China’s Tianjin Lishen to supply batteries for its new Shanghai car factory, making the current news look less believable. Although it seems like the ongoing news about a Tesla-CATL pair up lacks integrity, with CATL sort of denying its intend to work with Tesla (according to an updated news release), the news does look interesting and its effect upon the related companies seems noteworthy.

3. Is There Still a Bright Future for FutureBright?

Almost 12 months after posting our initial thesis on Future Bright Holdings (703 HK)Gambling on a Bright Future, we review FutureBright’s most recent results, raising questions on whether stalling improvement in the core restaurant business performance warrants taking chips off the table while waiting for key catalysts to materialise.

4. Navitas Gets An Agreed Deal with BGH

After 6 months of haggling and due diligence, debt negotiation, and structuring, global education company Navitas Ltd (NVT AU) has now signed a Board-recommended Scheme Implementation Deed with a consortium led by Australian Private Equity firm BGH Capital consortium which includes Navitas Founder Rod Jones (also the largest holder at 13%) and AustralianSuper.

The agreed Scheme Price of A$5.825 is a 6% uplift from the original A$5.50 offered in the preliminary, indicative, non-binding offer announced on 10 October 2018 and a 34% premium to the undisturbed price of 9 October 2018 of A$4.35/share.

This history is that the consortium came in at A$5.50 (plus another cash+RollCo scrip offer), a month or so later the company effectively rejected it by not allowing the consortium to do due diligence after management lifted earnings guidance. This upset a number of shareholders. In November the share price ranged from A$4.95-5.25 or so and Chairman Tracey Horton got only 51% support at the AGM that month. The shares fell briefly below A$4.70 in early January this year before BGH came back in mid-January with a “revised indicative offer” of A$5.825 whereupon the shares bounced from about A$4.90 to about A$5.50 then climbed to A$5.60+ on 10mm shares volume in 3 days. 

The shares hovered around A$5.58-5.62 for 6-7 weeks until the beginning of March, briefly traded into the A$5.70s, and then traded back down the last few days this week to the A$5.59-5.63 area.

On Thursday 21 March the shares were halted for the day, StreetTalk had an article about the deal being imminent, and late in the afternoon, the BGH SID was announced. 

Now we start the official process. The Scheme document is expected to be dispatched in May 2019 with a deal completed by end-June or early July. I expect this deal gets up.

5. Navitas (NVT AU): BGH Heads Towards Its First Major Acquisition

Navitas Ltd (NVT AU), an Australian-listed education company, entered into a binding agreement to be acquired by the BGH Consortium. As a reminder on 15 January 2019, the BGH Consortium bid against itself by offering a revised proposal of A$5.825 cash per share, 6% higher than its previous rejected offer.

In this briefing:

1. Naspers: Softbank Buyback a Guide for Naspers?

1. Naspers: Softbank Buyback a Guide for Naspers?

Recently, Softbank’s (9984 JP) shares jumped +18% after announcing a $5.5bn share buyback. Using Smartkarma’s holdco monitor, the discount to NAV had widened to around 55% prior to the announcement but is now sitting around 40-45%. There were a few key reasons for the buyback: (1) the Softbank Corp (9434 JP) (KK) IPO netted $20bn, giving the company the flexibility to do the buyback, and (2) Softbank is taking a more disciplined approach to further platform investments.

Both these arguments are also available to Naspers (NPN SJ) management and a move to buy back 5% of market cap is feasible and we believe would narrow the discount. The question is whether management are listening. They have been dismissive of buybacks in the past but this could change.

In this briefing:

1. CATL Could Be Tesla’s New Battery Supplier- Panasonic in Trouble?
2. Is There Still a Bright Future for FutureBright?
3. Navitas Gets An Agreed Deal with BGH
4. Navitas (NVT AU): BGH Heads Towards Its First Major Acquisition
5. Korean Stubs Spotlight: Close Out the Pair Trade Between Hyosung TNC & Hyosung Corp

1. CATL Could Be Tesla’s New Battery Supplier- Panasonic in Trouble?

The news released on the 11^th of March, about Tesla Motors (TSLA US) choosing CATL (A) (300750 CH) as battery supplier has focused much attention on the two companies and other battery suppliers. CATL which grabbed Panasonic Corp (6752 JP)’s leading position in the industry last year now seems to be grabbing the latter’s key customer as well. The news circulating states that, CATL could power Tesla’s Model 3 cars which Tesla is planning to start assembling at Tesla’s new factory near Shanghai. Following the release of this supposed deal, the stocks of the two companies moved positively, with CATL surging by almost 6.7% while Tesla rose by almost 2.4% during the day.  However, both parties have not commented on this news yet or made any formal announcement regarding such a potential deal. In our Insight, Tesla Drifting Away Could Leave Panasonic Struggling to Gain Traction in China, we mentioned that Tesla was looking to locally source its batteries in China and that CATL could potentially be one such supplier. However, in January this year, it was reported that Tesla had signed a preliminary agreement with China’s Tianjin Lishen to supply batteries for its new Shanghai car factory, making the current news look less believable. Although it seems like the ongoing news about a Tesla-CATL pair up lacks integrity, with CATL sort of denying its intend to work with Tesla (according to an updated news release), the news does look interesting and its effect upon the related companies seems noteworthy.

2. Is There Still a Bright Future for FutureBright?

Almost 12 months after posting our initial thesis on Future Bright Holdings (703 HK)Gambling on a Bright Future, we review FutureBright’s most recent results, raising questions on whether stalling improvement in the core restaurant business performance warrants taking chips off the table while waiting for key catalysts to materialise.

3. Navitas Gets An Agreed Deal with BGH

After 6 months of haggling and due diligence, debt negotiation, and structuring, global education company Navitas Ltd (NVT AU) has now signed a Board-recommended Scheme Implementation Deed with a consortium led by Australian Private Equity firm BGH Capital consortium which includes Navitas Founder Rod Jones (also the largest holder at 13%) and AustralianSuper.

The agreed Scheme Price of A$5.825 is a 6% uplift from the original A$5.50 offered in the preliminary, indicative, non-binding offer announced on 10 October 2018 and a 34% premium to the undisturbed price of 9 October 2018 of A$4.35/share.

This history is that the consortium came in at A$5.50 (plus another cash+RollCo scrip offer), a month or so later the company effectively rejected it by not allowing the consortium to do due diligence after management lifted earnings guidance. This upset a number of shareholders. In November the share price ranged from A$4.95-5.25 or so and Chairman Tracey Horton got only 51% support at the AGM that month. The shares fell briefly below A$4.70 in early January this year before BGH came back in mid-January with a “revised indicative offer” of A$5.825 whereupon the shares bounced from about A$4.90 to about A$5.50 then climbed to A$5.60+ on 10mm shares volume in 3 days. 

The shares hovered around A$5.58-5.62 for 6-7 weeks until the beginning of March, briefly traded into the A$5.70s, and then traded back down the last few days this week to the A$5.59-5.63 area.

On Thursday 21 March the shares were halted for the day, StreetTalk had an article about the deal being imminent, and late in the afternoon, the BGH SID was announced. 

Now we start the official process. The Scheme document is expected to be dispatched in May 2019 with a deal completed by end-June or early July. I expect this deal gets up.

4. Navitas (NVT AU): BGH Heads Towards Its First Major Acquisition

Navitas Ltd (NVT AU), an Australian-listed education company, entered into a binding agreement to be acquired by the BGH Consortium. As a reminder on 15 January 2019, the BGH Consortium bid against itself by offering a revised proposal of A$5.825 cash per share, 6% higher than its previous rejected offer.

5. Korean Stubs Spotlight: Close Out the Pair Trade Between Hyosung TNC & Hyosung Corp

On March 12th, 2019, we wrote a report on initiating a pair trade of going long Hyosung TNC Co Ltd (298020 KS) and going short Hyosung Corporation (004800 KS). (Korean Stubs Spotlight: A Pair Trade Between Hyosung Corp and Hyosung TNC).  This trade has worked out well and now we think this is a good time to close this trade.

The return on this pair trade was 8.2%. (This assumes no commission costs, pricing spreads, taxes, or borrowing cost) using closing share price as of March 12th to March 21st, 2019. This trade was made over a period of 9 days so the annualized returns would be 332%. 

We believe that Hyosung TNC is up so much in the past 9 days mainly because it appears that a few investors saw this stock as an undervalued stock that was being ignored by the market. In our report, Korean Stubs Spotlight: A Pair Trade Between Hyosung Corp and Hyosung TNC,  we mentioned that Hyosung TNC appears to be a turnaround story driven by the following four key factors: 

• Decline in raw material prices 
• Aggressive spandex investment in India 
• Stabilization of spandex prices in 2H19 
• Consolidation of the global spandex industry