In this briefing:
- Tencent Music (TME): Both Live Video and Music Fairly Valued, No Action
- Hyundai Motor & Hyundai Mobis Pair: Owner Buying Mobis May Create Divergence in Favor of Motor
- Exuberance of Korean Retail Investors About Jim Rogers Becoming an Outside Director of Ananti
- Takeda: Move Over Newton! Now It’s Spooky Action At a Distance
- Discovery Management Will Likely Soon Be Helping Narrow the Share Class Spread
1. Tencent Music (TME): Both Live Video and Music Fairly Valued, No Action
- We believe that TME is fairly valued based on peer companies’ price / sales ratios.
- The Chinese internet peer companies as comparison bases in valuation have declined significantly more than indices, we believe it is not a concern that indices declined further.
- We believe that the main business of music will grow strongly in 2019 and 2020 due to the rapid growth of both the paying user base and ARPU (Average Revenues per User per month).
2. Hyundai Motor & Hyundai Mobis Pair: Owner Buying Mobis May Create Divergence in Favor of Motor
- Hyundai Motor Co (005380 KS) and Hyundai Mobis (012330 KS) are way more correlated than what internal sales dependency suggests. Their 2Y correlation coefficient is 0.84. The scatter chart shows they are clearly cointegrated.
- The owner family potentially buying Mobis shares may create divergence in favor of Motor. They need to sell their Motor shares to buy Mobis shares. The higher Motor price and the lower Mobis price are, the happier and wealthier they become.
- Current price ratio is a little below 2Y stat mean. I expect it to reach a +0.5~1 σ level on 2Y SD. This is a 4.5~9% yield. I’d go long Motor and short Mobis to hunt for this.
3. Exuberance of Korean Retail Investors About Jim Rogers Becoming an Outside Director of Ananti
- After it was announced on 10 December that Jim Rogers was being considered an outside director of Ananti Inc (025980 KS), its share price has soared more than 100% in six business days. At current price of 21,000 won, market cap of Ananti is 1.7 trillion won ($1.5 billion). In six days, Jim Rogers has added more than $800 million in market cap to Ananti, which is now trading at more than 5.0x P/B, compared to 2.5x P/B only a week ago. We think the risk/reward of Ananti is no longer favorable given the steep share price increase.
- This is a classic “buy on rumor, sell on news” trading that could impact the share price. The fact is, Jim Rogers has not yet accepted to be an outside director of the company. Rather, he has been recommended to become an outside director to be decided on December 27th and there are only six more business days until this date. It is almost a given that Jim Rogers will be voted in as an outside director of Ananti. We think that there could be many investors that may be unloading their shares as we get closer to December 27th.
- In addition, there are many other companies that should benefit from a greater opening up of the North Korean economy to South Korea and rest of the world. We have listed the 30 key North Korean related stocks below. Hence, for those investors that want to get a greater exposure to the North Korea related stocks in South Korea, some of these other stocks may provide greater value than Ananti which has soared in price in such a short period of time.
4. Takeda: Move Over Newton! Now It’s Spooky Action At a Distance
Over the weekend I published Softbank Corp, Takeda, and Newton’s Three Laws of Motion. Newton’s Three Laws helpfully guide one to understanding the nature of interaction of forces and bodies and the motion which results. Later, Euler’s laws of motion applied a framework for rigid and continuum bodies, and since then “action at a distance” has been replaced be Einstein’s Theory of General Relativity.
After I wrote the bit about one part of the index impact, FTSE unhelpfully changed their mind on timing based on an unhelpful change by the LSE. On Monday, the TSE exercised its discretion – clearly stated in the TOPIX Index Guidebook on p4 (2nd sentence of the opening paragraph) as something it may do – to go its own course in how it will adapt index changes to the first couple of increases in share count due to mergers with foreign corporations.
If an event not specified in this document occurs, or if TSE determines that it is difficult to use the methods described in this document, TSE may use an alternative method of index calculation as it deems appropriate.
So with the changes at FTSE and now TOPIX and JPX Nikkei 400, we no longer have quite the same clarity of forces on the bodies, and therefore less clarity on the resulting motion. The LSE’s announced market change appears to have led the MSCI to change its deletion date for Shire as well, now also (along with FTSE) deleting Shire at the close of the 21st (announcement early this AM Asia time).
Investors have prepared based on the idea that there was a reasonably tight relationship – helped because it was a lot of force applied in a short period (selling and buying all done in a short period in January) between the particles. Now that relationship is being stretched. A lot.
The problem resembles that which Einstein famously pooh-poohed as “Spooky Action At a Distance”. Schrödinger called this entanglement – and it turns out to be one of the weirder branches of quantum mechanics – a field broken wide open by Bell’s Theorem a decade after Einstein shuffled off this mortal coil* – and about which John Wheeler famously said, “If you are not completely confused by quantum mechanics, you do not understand it.”
I cheerfully say quantum mechanics completely baffles me.
I less cheerfully say this whole episode with Takeda and index providers has baffled me too.
But it is important to note that the timing and implications are vastly different than expected just two trading days ago. And the difference is worth thinking about. When the FTSE/MSCI net sell of risk was just 3 days apart, there was a clear connection across that three day distance. Now, the 6-10 week spread of time between the FTSE/MSCI events, the weird two weeks of SETSqx illiquid purgatory just as everyone is full up of risk, then the walk through the Valley of the Shadow of Flowback before we get the first really good net index inclusion to cover the Shire risk people have been dumping for months means that the certainty of understanding the movement of the particle on the other side is substantially lower.
If it all works out well, it might just be Spooky Action At a Distance.
5. Discovery Management Will Likely Soon Be Helping Narrow the Share Class Spread
As share class trades go, Discovery has presented several opportunities over the years to take advantage of index changes, corporate events, and a management that has aggressively repurchased nonvoting DISCK shares versus voting DISCA shares.
